To The New York Times, it was a standard journalistic practice done in the name of fairness — asking someone involved in a story for comment. To the mother of the nominee for secretary of defense, it constituted a threat.
On Wednesday, Pete Hegseth's mother accused the Times of making “threats†by calling about its story on an email she had sent to her son six years earlier that criticized his treatment of women.
Penelope Hegseth sought and received an interview on Fox News Channel to support her son, whose by a series of damaging stories about his personal conduct. At one point, she said she wanted to directly tell President-elect Trump that her son “is not that man he was seven years ago.â€
She also called the Times “despicable†and attacked a basic tenet of journalism: giving someone the chance to speak for a story about actions that could be seen in a negative light.
The Times' story, , quoted from a private email that Penelope Hegseth sent to her son in 2018 while he was in the midst of divorcing his second wife. She criticized his character and treatment of women, suggesting that he get some help.
“I have no respect for any man that belittles, lies, cheats, sleeps around and uses women for his own power and ego,†she wrote to her offspring. “You are that man (and have been for many years).â€
His mother said the message was sent in a moment of anger
She told the Times for its story that she had sent the email in a moment of anger and followed it up two hours later with an apology. She disavows its content now.
When the Times called her for comment on the story, Hegseth told Fox News that, at first, she did not respond. She said she perceived the calls as a threat — “they say unless you make a statement we will publish it as is and I think that's a despicable way to treat anyone,†she said.
“I don't think a lot of people know that's the way they operate,†she said, speaking about the story. She accused the newspaper of being in it "for the money. And they don't care who they hurt, families, children. I don't believe that's the right way to do things.â€
Charles Stadtlander, a spokesman for the Times, said Hegseth's claim “is flatly untrue,†and she was in no way threatened. “The Times did what it always does in reporting out a story, simply reaching out and asking for a comment, which we included,†he said.
Such a call is the opposite of a threat — it's an attempt to be fair, said Tom Rosenstiel, a University of Maryland professor and co-author of “Elements of Journalism: What News People Should Know and What the Public Should Expect.†“She's basically saying that brake lights are a threat because they alert you that the car ahead of you is about to stop," he said.
But many Americans would perceive that call as a threat, or certainly as rude and a violation of privacy, said Tim Graham, director of media analysis at the conservative Media Research Center. “She didn't write that email to be on the front page of The New York Times,†he said.
What are the ethics of publishing a private email between mother and son?
A secondary question is the newsworthiness of publishing the content of the private email, one that Hegseth said she almost immediately regretted sending and doesn't reflect how she perceives her son. Graham suggested that the newspaper wouldn't do the same for the nominee of a Democratic president-elect. “The New York Times is out to destroy these nominees,†he said.
In its initial story, the Times wrote that it had obtained a copy of the email “from another person with ties to the Hegseth family.â€
“This was a piece of independently reported journalism published in the name of public awareness of the nominee to lead the largest department in the federal government,†Stadtlander said. “We stand behind it completely.â€
In many circumstances, an email from a mother to her son would be considered a private matter and out of bounds to a news organization, Rosenstiel said. But in this case, Hegseth, a former Fox News weekend host chosen by Trump to lead the Pentagon, has built himself into a public figure and is up for a very important job — and one that leads the military, which involves waging war and in which character is considered a fundamental trait.
“It makes this news, honestly,†Stadtlander said.
The Times wrote about Penelope Hegseth's Fox interview on Wednesday, leading with her saying her son “was not the same man he was in 2018 when she fired off an email accusing him of routinely abusing women and lacking decency and character.â€
There was some question about whether Hegseth would appear for an interview at his former network on Wednesday, after CNN's Kaitlan Collins the night before that “multiple people†said that was expected. A Fox News representative said that no such interview had been scheduled, and the nominee was on Capitol Hill meeting with senators.
He has faced a flurry of other damaging reports, including stories about reported to police in 2017. No charges were filed then, and Hegseth said the relationship was consensual. The New Yorker magazine wrote about , sexist behavior and excessive drinking when Hegseth ran a veterans' organization, and NBC News people at Fox News concerned about his alcohol use.
___
David Bauder writes about media for the AP. Follow him at and
